Private Softball Lessons in North Jersey
Personalized instruction built around your player, with experienced coaches and multiple training locations. Looking for a broader development path? Explore softball training in North Jersey.
Hitting • Fastpitch Pitching • Fielding • Catching
Not sure what to book? Call or text 973-355-7015 for help choosing a coach, location or lesson type, or send a quick lesson inquiry.
Meet Your Softball Coaches
The instructor matters. See who may work with your player before you ever get to the booking form.
Coach Steve Eisenstein
Collegiate coaching experience focused on player development, group training and SABRE program leadership. Limited private lesson availability.
Coach Steve Eisenstein
SABRE Softball Program Lead • Group Training
As Director of SABRE Softball, Coach Steve Eisenstein focuses on structured training, individual player development, communication with families and long-term program growth.
His collegiate coaching background includes serving as Head Softball Coach at Saint Elizabeth University and an assistant softball coach at Felician University. His coaching experience also includes Matawan, Princeton and Freehold high school programs.
A co-founder of the Central Jersey Tornado softball organization, Steve coached athletes from 10U through 18U and helped lead the program to a PONY National Championship in 1999. He also served as PONY Softball's Mid-Atlantic Regional Director.
At In The Zone, Steve leads group training and player development, helping athletes strengthen their skills, build confidence and develop sound practice habits. He also supports SABRE’s coaching staff and the program’s overall approach to training and competition.
Limited Private Lesson Availability: Steve’s primary focus is SABRE program leadership and group training. Private lessons may be available on a limited basis, subject to his program schedule. Contact In The Zone to discuss availability.
Coach Jamie Stefani
Delaware Valley head coach, two-time All-American and 2024 MAC Freedom Coach of the Year. Private pitching instruction based on openings in her coaching schedule.
Coach Jamie Stefani
Softball Pitching Instructor | Head Softball Coach, Delaware Valley University
A Budd Lake native and Mount Olive High School graduate, Coach Jamie Stefani returns to In The Zone with an exceptional background as both a collegiate softball player and successful head coach. Currently leading the softball program at Delaware Valley University, Jamie earned 2024 MAC Freedom Coach of the Year honors and guided the Aggies to a program-record 29 wins in 2026.
A two-time All-American, four-year team captain and four-time All-Conference selection during her playing career at Delaware Valley, Jamie excelled as both a pitcher and first baseman. She graduated among the most decorated players in program history, with achievements across the school’s offensive and pitching record books.
Since transitioning into collegiate coaching, Jamie has developed players, built competitive programs and elevated team performance. Her NCAA coaching experience provides valuable insight into the skills, preparation and mindset required to succeed at higher levels of softball.
At In The Zone, Jamie specializes in Softball pitching instruction, bringing her playing and coaching knowledge directly to developing athletes. Her approach emphasizes strong fundamentals, confidence, competitive preparation and helping pitchers reach their full potential.
Private lessons with Coach Jamie are available through In The Zone based on openings in her coaching schedule.
Coach Lia Milsom
Ramapo College outfielder and All-NJAC honoree helping players build skills, confidence and smart, aggressive play.
Coach Lia Milsom
Softball Instructor | Hitting, Defense, Slap Hitting (Slapping) & General Skills Development
A Roxbury native, Coach Lia Milsom brings an impressive combination of collegiate playing experience, athletic accomplishments, and a passion for teaching to In The Zone Baseball & Softball Academy. A standout center fielder at Ramapo College, Lia has been a three-year starter, making an immediate impact as a freshman by appearing in 27 games. Her collegiate achievements include earning Second Team All-NJAC honors in 2025, ranking fourth in Ramapo program history for career stolen bases, and helping her team reach three NCAA Regional tournaments.
Before Ramapo, Lia was a four-year varsity starter at Roxbury High School, earning Second Team All-Conference honors twice while helping lead her team to two sectional championships and a Group 3 State Championship. Her dedication extends beyond the field, earning recognition as a four-time NFCA All-America Scholar-Athlete and three-time CSC Academic All-District honoree.
At In The Zone, Lia focuses on hitting, defensive fundamentals, slap hitting (slapping), and overall softball skill development. Her experience as a collegiate outfielder and accomplished base stealer gives her valuable insight into the importance of speed, technique, and smart, aggressive play.
Currently studying Visual Arts and Secondary Education at Ramapo, Lia aspires to become a middle or high school art teacher and softball coach. Her passion for both athletics and education drives her commitment to helping young players strengthen their skills, build confidence, and develop a lasting love for the game.
Ariel Pagan
Hitting, catching, fundamentals, confidence and game understanding.
Ariel Pagan
Private Instructor • Hitting & Catching
Ariel Pagan has over 20 years of experience mentoring youth and more than seven years of coaching baseball and girls softball. His passion is helping young athletes develop their skills while building confidence, character, discipline, and a lifelong love for the game.
Ariel’s coaching philosophy is centered on teaching the game the right way by emphasizing fundamentals, accountability, teamwork, and creating a positive, competitive environment where every player has the opportunity to grow. He believes success is measured not only by wins and losses, but by the development of each athlete both on and off the field.
Coaching & Leadership Experience
- Head Coach, JTL Middle School Baseball (2022–2025)
- East Stroudsburg Little League Baseball Coach (2018–2023)
- Head Coach, East Stroudsburg Girls Softball – Summer & Fall Seasons (2023–2025)
- Vice President, East Stroudsburg Girls Softball Little League (2023–2025)
As a player, Ariel competed at a high level throughout his youth and high school career. At age 12, he was selected to play against the Puerto Rico Little League All-Star Team, an experience that helped shape his passion for baseball. He was named Athlete of the Year in high school while batting .526 as a junior and .475 as a senior.
Off the field, Ariel has dedicated his career to mentoring young people and helping them succeed in athletics, academics, and life. His goal is to develop confident athletes, strong teammates, and future leaders by creating a culture built on hard work, respect, and a love for the game.
Marisa Bogdonoff
Skill development, game preparation, confidence and competitive mindset.
Marisa Bogdonoff
Private Instructor • Group Training • Club Team Coach
Marisa Bogdonoff brings both high-level playing experience and a deep-rooted love for the game into everything she does on the field. A seven-time MVP, Marisa understands what it takes to compete, lead, and perform consistently over time.
She played collegiately at Kean University and went on to deepen her knowledge of the game through multiple coaching and operational roles. Marisa served as an intern and team manager for Cortland Softball, gaining a behind-the-scenes understanding of program culture, preparation, and accountability. She later coached with the PA Outlaws and was an assistant coach at Drew University, working closely with athletes on both skill development and mindset.
For Marisa, softball is more than mechanics and reps. It’s discipline. It’s resilience. It’s learning how to show up—focused, confident, and ready—every single day. She brings that perspective to her coaching, helping players not only get better at the game, but grow through it.
Amanda Novak
Pitching mechanics, accuracy, confidence and repeatability.
Amanda Novak
Softball Instructor • Pitching & Player Development
Coach Amanda Novak brings a strong combination of playing experience, coaching knowledge, and a passion for developing confident young athletes to In The Zone. A graduate of Immaculate Conception High School, Amanda was a team captain and state champion before continuing her softball career at Drew University.
A pitcher first, Amanda also contributed at multiple positions throughout her playing career, including first base, second base, third base, and the outfield. At Drew, she earned a degree in Psychology with a minor in Law, Justice, and Society and was recognized on the Dean's List for her academic performance. Amanda is currently pursuing her Master's degree in Forensic Psychology at Arizona State University.
Amanda has coached 16U and 18U club softball and has been providing private pitching instruction for more than two years, working with pitchers of all ages. Her pitching instruction places a strong emphasis on accuracy, confidence, and helping young athletes develop a repeatable approach in the circle.
With experience as both a collegiate pitcher and coach, Amanda focuses on helping athletes grow technically while also developing the confidence needed to compete. Her goal is to create a positive, supportive training environment where players can improve their skills, trust their abilities, and build a strong foundation for long-term success.
Natalie Dias
Middle-infield development, hitting, catching experience and fundamentals.
Natalie Dias
Softball Instructor • Infield, Hitting & Defensive Development
Natalie Dias brings a strong softball background and a player-first coaching approach to In The Zone Baseball & Softball Academy. A four-year varsity starter at West Morris Central High School, Natalie was a standout middle infielder, primarily playing shortstop and second base while also contributing behind the plate as a catcher. She earned First Team All-Conference honors during her high school career.
Natalie played competitive softball for 10 years and competed at the travel level with both In The Zone and Finch's Aces, giving her firsthand experience in the development path many young players are now working through themselves.
In addition to providing private instruction, Natalie serves as an assistant coach for the ITZ SABRE 12U Softball team, where she enjoys helping young athletes develop fundamentally while building confidence, improving their understanding of the game, and fostering a love for softball.
Currently a Psychology major at the University of Florida, Natalie combines her passion for softball with an understanding of how athletes learn, grow, and perform. Her positive, encouraging coaching style focuses on helping players improve their skills, build confidence, and reach their full potential both on and off the field.
Find Your Lesson
Choose your lesson type, location, instructor and preferred days to see current availability.
Live ITZ Lesson Finder
Live lesson options will appear here when ready. You can request help without waiting.
The live finder needs JavaScript. You can open the lesson finder directly.
Not Sure Who To Choose?
Choose “Any Available Instructor” in the lesson finder or let ITZ help match your player with the right coach and location.
Need Help Booking?
Call or text the Private Instruction Hotline at 973-355-7015.
What We Can Work On
Every lesson is built around the athlete’s current needs, skill level and goals.
Why Families Choose In The Zone
Individualized Coaching
Training is built around your player’s age, ability, goals and specific areas for improvement.
Multiple Training Locations
Train in Hackettstown, Mine Hill, Livingston or Morris Plains based on coach and facility availability.
Experienced Instructors
Work one-on-one with coaches who understand player development and know how to teach it.
Rapsodo-Certified Softball Training
Use objective data to support fastpitch and hitting development while keeping the coach-player relationship at the center of the lesson. Learn more about Rapsodo training at In The Zone.
Choose the Right Commitment
Start with one lesson or build consistency over a longer development plan.
Single Lesson
Try one-on-one instruction and see how your player responds.
Schedule within 30 days
5-Lesson Starter
Build fundamentals and establish consistent feedback.
Schedule within 90 days
10-Lesson Development
For athletes serious about measurable progress over time.
Use within 6 months
15-Lesson Elite
Longer-term development for travel and high school athletes.
Use within 8 months
Softball Lesson Reviews
Real feedback from families whose players have trained with In The Zone instructors.
“We cannot recommend In The Zone enough for softball training!”
Megan Campagna
“Not only did she help her with hitting, but also with her self esteem. She is a phenomenal coach and mentor!”
Crystal V.
“My daughter’s skills have grown tremendously and her confidence on and off the field has skyrocketed. The instructor’s willingness to share their knowledge and experiences is a unique approach that creates an inviting and friendly atmosphere.”
Stephanie James
Private Lesson FAQs
How do I choose the right instructor?
Compare the coach cards above, choose a preferred instructor in the live lesson finder, or select Any Available Instructor and let ITZ help with the match.
Can I train at more than one location?
Yes. Availability varies by instructor and site, and the live finder can show other location options based on your preferences.
What ages and skill levels do you work with?
ITZ works with beginners through travel, high school and advanced athletes. The lesson is adjusted to the player’s current level and goals.
Can I request a specific coach?
Yes. Choose a specific instructor in the live lesson finder, or select Any Available Instructor for the widest range of lesson times.
Ready To Start Softball Lessons?
Meet the coaches, use the live lesson finder, or contact ITZ for help choosing the right fit.




